Ratings 10/20/07  
Ratings (10/20)

Sometimes when you try to do something fast, it comes out being half-fast. Such is the case with the ratings I sent out two weeks ago. It turns out that in converting to a 240-team league I made a little programming mistake. The bottom line is that the last set of ratings were based only on wins and losses (no points) and were artificially compressed. After a face lift, this week's ratings are much more stretched out with a 97-point gap between the top and bottom teams. I'm still a little worried about bugs, but the more I look the less apologetic I am about LSU and USF 1-2. The Bulls at #2 looked a lot better before they lost, but their wins over West Virginia and Auburn are quality, the loss to Rutgers is not bad, and the win over Elon is better than a win over, for example, Notre Dame. I would personally rank Ohio State #1 and Arizona State #2, but it's interesting that strictly "by the numbers" the Buckeyes don't rate #1.

One thought that I had was that Ohio State is tied with Michigan in the Big 10. Michigan lost to Appalachian State, which is currently mired in 6th in the Southern Conference. One fun aspect of the ratings is that I can play "what if" by changing a result. So I gave Michigan a 3-point victory over Appalachian and ... not much changed. Ohio State went up half a point, but they were still 4th. Michigan gained 3 points, which moved them from 18th to 14th. So the disregard for the Big 10 is more deep-rooted than just the one game. Minnesota loses to North Dakota State, Iowa loses to Iowa State, etc., there are a number of bad losses. And playing Southern Conference teams is actually better for your rating than playing MAC teams.

Saturday was a little bit of "Empire Strikes Back" with Michigan, Florida, Alabama and UCLA winning big games. But we still have some interesting conference standings, with Virginia, UConn, Kansas, East Carolina, Central Michigan, Arizona State, Hawaii and everybody in the SEC East leading. And Temple has won three straight! Meanwhile, we can just enjoy the last-minute touchdowns and upsets!

There are several big games this week, starting Thursday night in Blacksburg. My ratings have this as #7 against #14 as opposed to #2 versus #8, but it is definitely an elimination game. A loss eliminates BC from the national championship picture, and possibly Matt Ryan from the Heisman. A BC win virtually eliminates everybody else from the ACC Atlantic Division race. A Hokie loss does not eliminate them from the Coastal crown, but it would drop them a game behind the happy Hoos down in Hooville. There are two big matchups in the wacky Big East and tests for unbeaten Ohio State, Kansas and Arizona State. Enjoy the games!

The following predictions are straight from the ratings, with 4 points added for home field.

Boston College over Virginia Tech by 1 (Lane is often worth more than 4 points, but BC doesn't make many mistakes)
Virginia over NC State by 13 (will Virginia know what to do if it gets ahead? They've won all the close ones.)
Maryland over Clemson by 2 (These two teams specialize in losing close ones. So it won't be close?)
South Florida over UConn by 7 (USF lost last week at Rutgers but the computer still believes)
West Virginia over Rutgers by 1 (can the Knights chop down another top 10 team? This might be for the title.)
Ohio State over Penn State by 5 (an old-fashioned 3 yards and a cloud of dust? 3 yards and a fumble return?)
Kansas over Texas A&M by 6 (the Fat Man has the Jayhawks on a roll, the Aggies may roll Coach Fran out)
Arizona State over Cal by 12 (the first of 4 big games for the Sun Devils, the Bears try to get back on track)
Oregon over Southern Cal by 14 (I would take SC and 14, but it's interesting that Oregon's record is this much better)
Florida over Georgia by 9 (the cocktail party might be a mismatch, but if Tebow is ailing ...)
South Carolina over Tennessee by 3 (the Ball Coach would like to beat somebody from the state of Tennessee)
Texas over Nebraska by 11 (two teams that thought they were going to be a lot better)

1 LSU 98.76
2 S. Florida 95.64
3 Oregon 94.60
4 Ohio State 94.09
5 Florida 93.84
6 Arizona St 92.23
7 Boston College 92.10
8 West Virginia 91.12
9 Kentucky 91.07
10 Kansas 90.64
11 Oklahoma 90.30
12 Auburn 90.02
13 Missouri 89.81
14 Virginia Tech 87.40
15 S Carolina 87.34
16 Virginia 86.55
17 Rutgers 86.24
18 Michigan 86.02
19 Alabama 85.49
20 Georgia 85.02
21 Penn State 84.57
22 UConn 84.53
23 Kansas State 84.36
24 California 84.26
25 Southern Cal 84.22
26 UCLA 83.68
27 Wake Forest 83.63
28 Clemson 83.19
29 Arkansas 82.56
30 Oklahoma St 82.32
31 Texas 82.07
32 Georgia Tech 81.72
33 Purdue 81.21
34 Cincinnati 81.13
35 Maryland 80.86
36 Vanderbilt 80.78
37 Illinois 80.77
38 Boise St 80.62
39 Texas A&M 80.52
40 Michigan St 80.36
41 Tennessee 80.12
42 Florida State 79.93
43 Texas Tech 79.92
44 BYU 79.54
45 Colorado 79.14
46 N Iowa 78.70
47 Air Force 78.49
48 Wisconsin 78.23
49 Oregon St 77.95
50 Miami F 77.48
51 Washington 77.39
52 Troy 77.01
53 UNC 76.55
54 Navy 76.10
55 Nebraska 75.27
56 Louisville 75.19
57 Utah 75.17
58 UMass 75.12
59 C. Florida 74.76
60 Stanford 74.46
61 Miss St 74.44
62 Hawaii 74.43
63 New Mexico 74.29
64 Indiana 74.11
65 Wyoming 74.05
66 Appalachian 73.77
67 Houston 73.70
68 Ball State 73.69
69 Pittsburgh 73.67
70 Fresno St 73.50
71 East Carolina 72.89
72 Elon 72.75
73 Northwestern 72.70
74 Florida Atlantic 72.40
75 N Dakota St 72.22
76 Yale 71.52
77 S Illinois 71.42
78 TCU 71.11
79 Wofford 70.95
80 JMU 70.94
81 Bowling Green 70.86
82 NC State 70.71
83 McNeese St 70.28
84 Ole Miss 70.16
85 New Hampshire 69.04
86 Tulsa 68.97
87 Central Michigan 68.90
88 Middle Tenn 68.33
89 Duke 67.89
90 Iowa 67.86
91 Akron 67.66
92 Arizona 67.53
93 Miami O 67.39
94 Notre Dame 67.38
95 Richmond 67.08
96 Delaware 66.73
97 Holy Cross 66.44
98 Ga South 65.87
99 West.Kentucky 65.73
100 Washington St 65.69
101 Nevada 65.15
102 Kent State 64.98
103 UTEP 64.92
104 West.Michigan 64.76
105 Hofstra 64.60
106 Youngstown 64.47
107 Villanova 64.43
108 Montana 64.35
109 Army 64.06
110 Southern Miss 63.94
111 Buffalo 63.82
112 Minnesota 63.52
113 Citadel 63.40
114 E Kentucky 63.10
115 Baylor 63.10
116 Syracuse 63.07
117 Arkansas St 63.03
118 San Diego St 62.38
119 La Tech 62.37
120 Colorado St 62.37
121 Grambling 62.27
122 Temple 61.92
123 UNLV 61.50
124 San Jose 61.02
125 Ohio 60.64
126 New Mexico St 60.18
127 S Dakota St 59.78
128 W Illinois 59.73
129 Toledo 59.72
130 Iowa State 59.60
131 Memphis 58.99
132 La-Lafayette 58.87
133 La-Monroe 58.42
134 SC State 58.05
135 Wm & Mary 57.89
136 Illinois St 57.89
137 Norfolk St 57.88
138 East.Michigan 57.53
139 E.Wash. 57.51
140 Harvard 57.36
141 Tulane 57.21
142 Alabama A&M 57.07
143 UAB 57.04
144 Furman 56.42
145 Montana St 56.17
146 Nicholls St 55.82
147 Delaware St 55.74
148 Cornell 55.09
149 Chattanooga 55.09
150 Marshall 54.61
151 Colgate 54.44
152 Southern 53.82
153 Fordham 53.77
154 San Diego 53.75
155 Utah State 53.43
156 Missouri St 53.30
157 Jackson St 53.30
158 Towson 53.27
159 Rice 53.08
160 Central Ark 52.63
161 Jacksonville St 52.56
162 Sam Houston 52.51
163 Florida Int. 52.36
164 Liberty 52.18
165 Lehigh 52.13
166 Northern Illinois 52.10
167 Cal Poly 52.09
168 Dayton 51.44
169 E Illinois 51.39
170 Hampton 51.23
171 Idaho 51.00
172 SMU 50.80
173 UC Davis 50.74
174 North Texas 50.68
175 N Arizona 50.68
176 Albany 50.32
177 Gardner Webb 49.94
178 Northeastern 49.88
179 W Carolina 49.30
180 Prairie View 48.07
181 Rhode Island 47.76
182 Stony Brook 47.74
183 Coastal Car 47.32
184 Dartmouth 47.24
185 Maine 46.47
186 Texas St 46.44
187 Penn 46.41
188 Brown 45.14
189 Lafayette 45.11
190 Portland St 45.01
191 Tenn St 44.97
192 Weber St 44.89
193 Drake 44.58
194 Alabama St 44.34
195 S Utah 44.24
196 Cen Conn 44.24
197 Iona 44.07
198 Winston Salem 44.04
199 Sacramento St 43.84
200 SE La 42.88
201 Idaho St 42.83
202 Morgan St 42.49
203 Florida A&M 42.34
204 Austin Peay 42.30
205 NW State 40.27
206 Princeton 39.82
207 Ark PB 39.73
208 Morehead 39.40
209 Davidson 38.63
210 Wagner 38.48
211 Charleston S 38.43
212 VMI 37.97
213 Howard 37.86
214 Samford 37.72
215 Tenn Martin 37.44
216 Miss Valley 37.40
217 Bethune Cookman 37.04
218 Tenn Tech 36.90
219 SF Austin 36.34
220 Bucknell 36.28
221 Murray St 35.53
222 Georgetown 35.40
223 SE Missouri 34.44
224 Alcorn 34.27
225 Duquesne 33.19
226 Robert Morris 32.17
227 Monmouth 31.73
228 Indiana St 31.38
229 Valparaiso 30.37
230 N Colorado 29.69
231 Jacksonville 29.10
232 Columbia 28.76
233 NC A&T 27.56
234 Sacred Heart 22.40
235 Butler 20.93
236 Texas Southern 20.00
237 St Francis 19.32
238 Marist 17.04
239 Savannah St 13.99
240 LaSalle 1.57